2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

2008 NBA All-Star Game - New OrleansAs a fan, I always get a little excited as the NBA All-Star Game rolls around each year.  I get to vote, so naturally, I'd like to see the players I vote for get selected as starters for the game.  There are millions of other fans who get to vote as well, which means I probably don't get to see who I want... no biggie.

Each year, as the All-Star starters are announced, arguments can be made for the players that made it, and typically more arguments for those that got snubbed (Peter Vecsey - New York Post).  While I think the fans did a very respectable job this time around, I still feel that a few players are undeserving of their selections.

In total support of Vecsey's column above, the All-Star game should really be a showcase of the league's top talent.  Yes, Jason Kidd and Dwyane Wade are exceptional basketball players, but Kidd can't hit a shot to save his life (or is he tanking to get traded) and Wade can't even beat a Garnett/Allen/Pierce-less Celtics team (Pierce played, but scored less than 10 pts, so he basically wasn't there).  Wade has also been injured and missed a number of games this year - that should be a factor (see McGrady comments further below).

Eastern Conference Starters - Kevin Garnett, Lebron James, Jason Kidd, Dwyane Wade & Dwight Howard (Copyright NBAStore.com)

I voted several times and admit, it was harder to find more deserving Guards in the Eastern Conference, but Detroit's Chauncey Billups surely should've been selected.  It doesn't help that the East only has 6 teams with a winning record either.  Joe Johnson would've been a safe bet also, for his team's near .500 record.

In the Western Conference, it's hard to argue the selections.  The fans even did justice by allowing T-Mac to fall out of the starting spot in favor of Allen Iverson.  McGrady is of the opinion that players who are hurt (or have been for a good portion of the season) shouldn't be starters; I can't argue with that. 

Western Conference Starters - Yao Ming, Carmelo Anthony, Kobe Bryant, Allen Iverson & Tim Duncan (Copyright NBAStore.com)

There are three other positions/players that probably should've been different, but again, it's hard to argue w/ the selections.  I believe Tim Duncan got nominated purely on his history - he's not all that this year (see last night's loss to the Sonics).  With Iverson starting at PG, that leaves out both Steve Nash and Chris Paul - (2nd & 1st in the Western Conference, respectively).  I also don't think that two Nuggets are deserving of starting nods - Denver is tied for the 8th playoff spot in the West.

The reserves will be selected very soon and all of the players mentioned here will surely make it, with the exception of McGrady perhaps. 

For our Phoenix Suns, I do believe that Nash, Amare Stoudemire (C) and Shawn Marion (SF?) will all make the reserve squad.  One can only hope...


Published Wednesday, January 30, 2008 2:34 PM by chowell
Filed under:


Thursday, January 31, 2008 12:53 AM by Scott Mitchell

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

You know whose absent from the starting lineup for the first time in 15 STRAIGHT YEARS? Mr. Shaquille O'Neal. The last time Shaq WASN'T in the All Star game's starting lineup, I was a Freshman in high school. Wow.
Thursday, January 31, 2008 12:01 PM by chris paul

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better


Thursday, January 31, 2008 7:23 PM by bruck Henne

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

i think steve nash should be mvp but is he in the all star game
Saturday, February 02, 2008 12:14 AM by Smitty

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

Baron Davis, Manu Ginobili, Tony Parker, Hedo Turkoglu, Stephen Jackson, Josh Howard, Al Jefferson, Chris Kaman, and why not Marcus Camby!!!! Anyone listed not having an "ALL STAR" season up to this point? Play Fair!!!
Saturday, February 02, 2008 12:21 AM by chowell

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

I'm sorry, Ginobili and Parker have missed too much time to be considered.  Duncan is good enough to represent the Spurs.

Baron Davis and Camby are both pretty big omissions, but who do you replace?  If you take out Boozer, an argument could be made for Deron Williams.  

Maybe we need an All-Star tournament... 3 teams of 8.  Haha...

Wednesday, February 06, 2008 7:11 PM by Connecting News, Commentaries and Blogs at NineReports.com

# Related News Stories

Western Conference NBA All-Stars ...Blogged about at 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could&1;ve Done Better - nba weblog, These top Western conference players will take on the Eastern conference in the 2008 NBA All-Star game.

Friday, February 15, 2008 9:47 AM by michael

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

ben gordan.......where is he?!?!?!? the dude is insanly good!!!
Friday, February 15, 2008 10:01 AM by chowell

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

Ben Gordon is a solid player, but he's a 6th man and he's injured.

His team isn't good enough either unfortunately...

When he's starting and producing, then it definitely becomes a bigger argument.

Friday, February 15, 2008 10:06 AM by chowell

# re: 2008 NBA All-Star Starters... We Could've Done Better

KG to miss the All-Star Game - will be replaced by the red-hot Pistons' Rasheed Wallace. (And no, Rasheed isn't on fire, his team is).  

Seriously, this is the best guy they could find as a replacement?  Let's start putting the best players, regardless of conference in if this is the best they can do.

Ray Allen from the Celtics has been chosen by David Stern as a replacement for Caron Butler, who is also injured.